NO STRINGS? THE EFFECTS OF CASUAL SEX ON YOUR MENTAL HEALTH

STUART NUGENT AND DR. LAURIE MINTZ·APRIL 13, 2024

4 MINS READ

This article was scientifically reviewed by Human Sexuality expert Dr. Laurie Mintz. She is a professor, researcher, private practitioner and Fellow of the American Psychological Association.

Website | Academics | Instagram

Fact: We’re having sex earlier and getting married older. That means there are more years between adolescence and commitment for most of us, leaving more time for sexual adventure and casual hook-ups.

Like it or loathe it, that’s the way of the world we live in. Some say we are a reckless and hedonistic generation, and the fashionable term ‘no-strings sex’, or ‘NSA’, implies that casual sex is just sex without consequence.

Those of us who engage in casual sex may have to deal with a range of emotional consequences that persist even after the sex itself has faded from memory, quite aside from the physical risks of STIs and unwanted pregnancy.

Now, full disclosure, we’re overlooking all the positives of healthy, informed casual sex for this piece. There are many, many benefits from being stable and sexually empowered, so while it might seem like we’re condemning it here, we’re not.

Modern Sex

Despite the digital age in which we live, many of our cultural sensibilities remain anchored in the 20th century, which in turn took its cues from the 19th century, and so on. The development of our sexual identity and sense of sexual expression is fast outstripping changes in wider social attitudes to them.

The time-old sexual double-standard still unfortunately applies: Our society condemns women who engage in casual sex, but glorifies – or, at least, fails to blame men to the same extent. Whether or not there’s a biological foundation to this prejudice, it’s impossible to separate it from its cultural preconceptions.

What do we know about the emotional results of frequent liaisons? Well, there are many. First, there’s discomfort that comes from the sense that by engaging in casual sex, we’ve violated our own standards.

Working for a sex toy brand, I’m part of that messaging myself, after all. But that can put contradictory pressure on a person: to feel free to have casual sex, it’s something they should be doing because everyone else is.

Indeed, feelings of regret, disappointment, confusions, shame, and guilt are reported by those who engage in NSA sex regularly. (Although, it’s equally common to report feelings of nervous excitement, pride, being glad for the experience.)

Most tellingly, though, feelings of depression and loneliness can often be amplified after casual sex, even by those who have no usual depressive tendencies.

Researchers examining the mental health associations of hookup sex among college students reported that participants who were not depressed before showed more depressive symptoms and loneliness after engaging in casual sex. This study was of about 4,000 ethnically and socioeconomically diverse straight college students.

(It’s this sex study, if you’re interested). The base framework for the study is simple: the students were asked how many times in the last 30 days they’d had a sexual encounter with someone they’d known for less than a week. Then, they are asked to rate their self-esteem, level of life satisfaction, and general sense of psychological well being. To measure the negative feelings, they are then asked to report their feelings of depression, general anxiety, and social anxiety.

18.6% of men and 7.4% of women had had sex with a relative stranger at least once in the past month, for an average of 11% of college students.

So, What did the Study Show?

As you might expect, those who engaged in more casual sex also experienced more psychological distress, lower self-esteem, life satisfaction and happiness than those who had not recently had sex with a relative stranger. Those who had recently had casual sex also reported higher levels of depression, and higher general and social anxiety.

So far, so predictable. But, less predictably, the study also showed that those feelings were not different across the genders. For both male and female college students, engaging in casual sex negatively impacted emotional health.

In Summary

I know I’ve made it sound like all of us who engage in casual sex for the sake of casual sex will feel worse after. I know from experience that that isn’t the case in all cases. Likewise, research on casual sex points to a mix of positive and negative emotions. Still, the point of this article is one must be aware of the negative emotional consequences. If you are experiencing them, you are not alone – regardless of if they come with or without positive feelings as well.

Casual sex is a choice and if it’s making you feel bad, you can choose to not engage with it and/or seek out a mental health professional. Just know that no strings attached sex comes with some strings – and those strings may be your negative emotional state.

STUART NUGENT

With 16 years in the adult industry, including many years at LELO, it's fair to say Stu has been around the sex toy block a few times. As LELO's resident sex geek, he's been featured in the Independent, the Guardian, HuffPost, Vice, Cosmopolitan, and anywhere people talk about sex. Here on Volonte, he turns his spotlight onto the important events affecting sex right now in a regular op-ed. Views are his own.