TOP 5 ANAL TOYS FOR FIRST-TIMERS

NATASHA WEISS·APRIL 21, 2025

6 MINS READ

Are you interested in exploring anal play but don’t quite know where to start? Anal play can be incredibly exciting and fun, yet can also be a bit nervewracking – especially if you’re brand new to it.

Yet it can be incredibly pleasurable as long as you take into account some basic tips and also find toys for you and your body. Anal play is totally natural no matter your gender, and is a normal part of your sexuality to explore.

This guide will cover our top recommended anal toys for beginners so you can compare their features, and learn how to use them safely. Whether you’re exploring solo or with a partner, these toys are perfect for first time anal play.

What To Look for in a Beginner Anal Toy

As with any sex toy, the right anal toy comes down to personal preference. There are however some key things to consider when exploring beginner anal toys:

Size: Start small, go bigger as you're comfortable. Materials: Body-safe silicone, glass, or steel. Flared base: Essential for safe use. Shape: Tapered tips ease insertion. Flexible vs. firm: Soft silicone for beginners, firmer for control.

Top 5 Anal Toys for First-Timers

We know you’re eager to get started on your anal adventures, but take your time perusing these options for the best anal toys for beginners.

1. Small Silicone Butt Plug (Best Overall for Beginners)

These are smaller sized butt plugs made from body-safe silicone with a tapered tip and flared base.

Why It’s Great:

These are great because a silicone anal toy is soft and flexible allowing for a gentle introduction into anal play.

These butt plugs feature a tapered tip for easy insertion and removal. Their small size and comfortable shape make them perfect for beginners. Plus, the flared base means you’ll be safe throughout the experience, from start to finish.

Best for: Those completely new to anal play.

How To Use: Apply plenty of lube, relax, and insert slowly. Take some deep breaths and take a break if needed. This can feel intense at first, even with small butt plugs.

Beginner’s Prostate Massager (Best for Those with a Prostate)

Prostate massagers are designed to stimulate the prostate.

The LELO BILLY 2 has an intuitive four-button interface designed to offer ease of use while you switch between various pleasure settings, along with an impeccable shape sculpted for deep and satisfying stimulation.

Why It’s Great:

The curved design targets the prostate for intense pleasure, yet they are slim and non-intimdating for beginners.

Prostate massagers made from soft silicone allow for comfort and flexibility, leading to intense prostate orgasms.

Best for: Those with a prostate looking to explore internal prostate stimulation.

Insert slowly and explore the different settings on your device to see what prostate sensations feel best to you.

Glass Anal Plug (Best for Temperature Play & Easy Cleaning)

Glass anal plugs may seem a bit intimidating at first, but they’re simple to use and great for your next step in exploring anal toys.

Why It’s Great:

These are great because non-porous, hypoallergenic glass is incredibly easy to clean. Sleek glass makes them smooth and comfortable for effortless insertion.

Glass toys are fun for exploring temperature play because glass can be heated up or cooled down to feel all sorts of fun sensations.

Best for: Users who want to explore temperature play and have easy maintenance.

How To Use: Experiment with cooling or heating the toy in warm/cold water before play.

Common Mistakes To Avoid as a Beginner

Part of preparation is knowing what not to do, so be mindful of these common mistakes to avoid when trying out anal toys for the first time:

Skipping lubrication: This can cause discomfort or microtears (which can also increase your risk of contracting an STI). Using the wrong toy: Toys without a flared base are unsafe and risky. You’ll also want the right toy for your body! Going too fast: This can lead to pain and discomfort. Not cleaning toys properly: Always wash toys before and after use to prevent infections and prolong the life of your toys. Ignoring comfort levels: Always listen to your body and take breaks if needed.

Enjoy Your New Anal Toys

Anal play can take a bit of practice to get the hang of and can also be intense if you’re new to it. That’s why it’s so important to choose beginner-friendly anal toys. Still, you can explore and experiment with different types of toys to find what you like best.

Above all, when trying a new toy, explore at your own pace and prioritize your comfort and safety. Now that you know what options there are when it comes to anal toys for beginners, you can see what speaks to you. Just don’t forget the lube!

Discover pleasure with: